Church feels ‘great joy’ as 12-year-old gives birth
Categories: Pregnancy and child birthThe birth of a child with a 12-year-old mother was last night described as a “great joy” by the Catholic Church in Scotland.
The case of the Devon schoolgirl who was paid to go ahead with her pregnancy by Cardinal Winning’s Pro-Life Initiative provoked outrage when it was revealed by the Sunday Herald last year. The Church was accused of putting dogma before the girl’s best interest, while the Cardinal was praised by pro-life supporters all around the world for his controversial project.
Last night, the furious row was re-ignited as it emerged the girl, who is believed to have learning difficulties and to be under the care of the social services, has given birth.
While Scotland’s prominent pro-life lobby celebrated the birth, pro-choice campaigners lamented the predicament of the 12-year-old mother.
Father Danny McLoughlin, spokesman for the Catholic Church in Scotland, said: “Of course its always a great joy that a child is born, irrespective of the circumstances. It is great that the child is born and that the mother and child are well.”
Jim Dowson, of militant anti-abortion group Precious Life, hopes the child will deter other women from going ahead with terminations.
He said: “I think this is marvellous. I hope when people see that wee child they will look upon it and realise that was once a foetus which could have been aborted. That is a life saved and a life for the future.”
But pro-choice groups criticised the Catholic Church for coercing the young girl to go ahead with the pregnancy.
Jane Roe, of the Abortion Law Reform Association, said: “A 12- year-old is still a child. There is no way at all that a child of that age is ready physically or emotionally to give birth. And if they do give birth they need an enormous amount of professional support and family support, I just hope that is what the girl is getting.”
Gill Hubbart, of the Pro-Choice Action Group recently set up to counter the Precious Life campaign, said she was saddened by the news.
She said: “I think what is of concern is that there must have been enormous pressure on this girl to go through with the birth of this child. My understanding is that her parents and the Church wanted her to have it, and that saddens me.
“The danger now is that this girl will be pointed out as a young single mother and people will always say, ‘How terrible’.”
Both Social Services and the hospital in Devon refused to confirm or deny the birth last night, but the girl is thought to have had her child in the past few days.
It is not known whether the baby is a boy or a girl or whether the schoolgirl mother will be allowed to keep her child. The father is believed to be a teenage boy.
The local authority has known for some time that the girl was pregnant and took out a High Court injunction last year banning reporting of details which could lead to her identification. A Devon and Cornwall police spokesperson said its child protection team was working with social services to look after the girl and her family.
The case caused a world-wide controversy when it emerged during the girl’s pregnancy that the Roman Catholic Church’s Scotland-based Pro-Life Initiative was offering her financial help in the form of baby equipment.
Roseann Ready, of the Pro-Life Initiative, last night refused to comment on the birth but a spokesman for Cardinal Winning said: “This was a fairly unique set of circumstances that the girl found herself in and it called for a unique response.
“No-one is happy when a child of 12 falls pregnant but once it became clear she was pregnant we were dealing with two lives and not one. If it is now true that the child is born healthy and strong, then that is one piece of good news to emerge from these traumatic circumstances.”
Just more than a week ago another 12-year-old schoolgirl gave birth to a 6lb13oz boy in the toilet of her home in Plymouth, Devon, after not realising she was pregnant.