Benefits of oral contraceptives
Categories: Ovarian Cervical Uterine CancerBenefits of Oral Contraceptives The substantial and widespread benefits of oral contraceptives are often taken for granted or forgotten amid the controversies and concerns about the pill that range from legitimate scientific questions to unfounded neighborhood rumors. The chief benefit of OCs, of course, is their effectiveness in preventing pregnancy. OCs protect millions of women from the burden of unwanted pregnancies and childbearing and prevent thousands of women’s deaths in childbearing. Other important benefits of OCs are reductions in the risks of iron-deficiency anemia and of endometrial and ovarian cancer.
The fertility-related benefits of oral contraceptives include not only:
* Effectively preventing unwanted pregnancy, but also
* Better maternal and child survival,
* Prevention of ectopic pregnancy, and
* Reduced risk of pelvic inflammatory disease.
Preventing pregnancy. The most important benefit of the pill is its convenient, highly effective, and reversible protection against unwanted pregnancy. All widely available types of pills–combined estrogen-progestin, progestin-only, and multiphasics–are highly effective. Among women using combined estrogen-progestin OCs correctly, in the first year of use pregnancy occurs in fewer than one in every 100.
Most authorities consider combined pills containing less than 50 [mu]g of estrogen to be as effective as those containing 50 [mu]g or more. The few comparative studies have reported no significant difference (48, 259, 313).
Few studies have been conducted in which women were randomly assigned to use one type of pill or the other. A multicenter World Health Organization (WHO) study compared six combined OCs containing 20 to 50 [mu]g estrogen. No significant differences in effectiveness appeared. Even the highest pregnancy rate observed was less than 1.5 pregnancies per 100 woman-years of use (545).
Progestin-only pills may be slightly less effective than any combined pills. In clinical trials failure rates range from about 1 to 3 per 100 woman-years of use. While minipills fail to prevent ovulation in about 40 percent of users, other effects contribute to contraceptive protection. In particular, progestins change cervical mucus so that sperm find it more difficult to penetrate (153, 194, 398, 511).
Because all pills are so effective, identifying any small differences in effectiveness among specific formulations would require very large studies. In clinical trials other factors may be more important than formulation. Such factors include differences among pill groups in age and other characteristics of women recruited, the number lost to follow-up, and compliance with the pill-taking regimen (487).
Because women sometimes forget to take their pills, switch to another method, or discontinue contraceptive use altogether, actual effectiveness in day-to-day use is often less than reported in clinical trials. Surveys of married women in the US have found that 2 to 3 percent of women have unplanned pregnancies in the first year of pill use (170, 171, 432, 499). Actual failure rates are probably somewhat higher, however, since abortions are seriously underreported in most surveys (143, 205).
In some developing countries OC failure rates have been much higher. For example, according to World Fertility Survey data from five Latin American countries in the 1970s, the pregnancy rate among OC users was 8 per 100 per year. By comparison, the pregnancy rate among IUD users was 5 ler 100 (165). In the Philippines a 1980 national survey reported 19 pregnancies per 100 woman-years of pill use compared with 4 per 100 among IUD users (273). Other population-based surveys report pregnancy rates among OC users of 15 per 100 woman-years in Bangladesh (85) and 13 per 100 woman-years in Sri Lanka (480). Irregular pill-taking may explain these relatively high pregnancy rates.
Multiphasic pills have only recently been widely used, but some evidence suggests that one triphasic formulation may be slightly less effective than combined pills. During their first year on the market in Britain, several pregnancies were reported among users of a triphasic pill consisting of .05/.075/.125 mg levonorgestrel and 30/40/30 [mu]g ethinyl estradiol (133, 173). Subsequently, a study in the Netherlands found that, from 1982 to 1984–when this triphasic formulation was the only one marketed–women using triphasics were about twice as likely to request abortions as were users of combined pills (259). Finally, a 6-month clinical trial conducted in 11 centers in Denmark, Norway, and Sweden reported three pregnancies in 1,063 cycles among women using the formulation, two of the pregnancies attributed to pill failure (101).
Maternal and child health. By preventing unwanted pregnancies and enabling women to time births, OCs–like other reliable methods of contraception–contribute to both maternal and child health. Worldwide, an estimated half a million women die in pregnancy and childbirth every year. About 99 percent of these deaths occur in developing countries, where, excepting China, on average 550 women die per 100,000 live births, or one for every 180 live births (422). Among children, as many as 20 percent of infants die in parts of Africa and Asia. Worldwide each year an estimated 14 million children die before age five (174).